5 Best Backpack Coolers in 2024 to Stay Chill All Summer

All the top backpack coolers tested, reviewed, and compared

CoolerSpy is supported by readers. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

by  Cooler Bill Barton | Last Updated: 
best backpack coolers

With so many backpack coolers on the market, it’s almost impossible to know which one is the best. And with such a wide range of prices, it’s easy to wonder if you’re getting ripped off.

That’s why I bought several backpack coolers and tested them all against each other, including how much they hold, how long they keep ice, and how they feel on your back when fully loaded.

Compare All
Our Top Pick Badge CoolerSpy
Icemule Pro XL 33L Image Icemule Pro XL 33L
Upgrade Pick Badge CoolerSpy 1
YETI Hopper M20 Backpack Cooler Image YETI Hopper M20
Best on a Budget Badge CoolerSpy
Igloo MaxCold Voyager Backpack Image Igloo MaxCold Voyager
Overall Score
83
90
73
Bottom Line The insulation for the Icemule Pro was nearly as powerful as the YETI Hopper, which I didn’t expect. And the ergonomic design and loads of padding on the back and shoulders makes this an easy cooler to travel with all day. This is the best value for money backpack cooler I’ve found. The YETI Hopper M20 is the best-in-class backpack cooler I’ve tested. It’s by far the most comfortable and it also has the best ice retention. But it’s also the most expensive, and depending on your use-case, you might not need something as robust as the Hopper M20. If you want the best of the best, get the YETI backpack cooler. But if your budget is tight, look at Icemule. This ugly little beast is the best budget backpack cooler I tested. It held more cans and was better at insulating compared to the Tourit. The Igloo MaxCold Voyager has a great price, though I’d bet you’ll be looking for a new backpack cooler in three or four years, as it’s not the most durable.
Pros
  • 100% waterproof if sealed properly
  • 33 liter capacity, which is the most on this list
  • Puncture resistant against fishing hooks and pocket knives
  • The best insulating power of any backpack cooler I’ve tested
  • Very comfortable design that’s able to carry a lot of weight without discomfort
  • The MagShield Access opening is fantastic—easy to open and close and it’s perfectly air-tight
  • Best space efficiency
  • Under $100
  • Lots of pockets make it great for a picnic, where you’re bringing food and drinks
Cons
  • No separate carrying compartments
  • The inside has an extremely strong chemical smell that lasts for several weeks
  • Quite ugly
  • More of an insulated backpack than a true cooler
Value (10%)
10
6
9
Capacity (10%)
8
7
8
Insulation (30%)
8
9
6
Durability (20%)
9
10
7
Ease Of Use (15%)
7
10
8
Portability (10%)
9
10
8
Features (5%)
7
9
7
Buy Now Check Price Check Price Check Price
Specs Icemule Pro XL 33L YETI Hopper M20 Igloo MaxCold Voyager
Shelf Life of Food (Measured Days Below 40ºF) 27 hours 28 hours
ConstructionRubberized ripstop fabric and nylonDryHide high density knit fabricNylon
Show All Specifications
Compare All
Our Top Pick Badge CoolerSpy
Icemule Pro XL 33L Icemule Pro XL 33L
Overall Score
83
Bottom Line The insulation for the Icemule Pro was nearly as powerful as the YETI Hopper, which I didn’t expect. And the ergonomic design and loads of padding on the back and shoulders makes this an easy cooler to travel with all day. This is the best value for money backpack cooler I’ve found.
Pros
  • 100% waterproof if sealed properly
  • 33 liter capacity, which is the most on this list
  • Puncture resistant against fishing hooks and pocket knives
Cons
  • No separate carrying compartments
Value (10%)
10
Capacity (10%)
9
Insulation (30%)
8
Durability (20%)
9
Ease Of Use (15%)
7
Portability (10%)
9
Features (5%)
7
Get It Check Price
Specs Icemule Pro XL 33L
Does it Fit a Wine or 2L Bottle Standing Upright?Yes
Exterior Dimensions14”x11”x24”
Frosty Brew Rating32 hours
Safe Meat Rating27 hours
True Liquid Capacity33
Weight4 lbs empty
Show All Specifications
Compare All
Upgrade Pick Badge CoolerSpy 1
YETI Hopper M20 Backpack Cooler YETI Hopper M20
Overall Score
90
Bottom Line The YETI Hopper M20 is the best-in-class backpack cooler I’ve tested. It’s by far the most comfortable and it also has the best ice retention. But it’s also the most expensive, and depending on your use-case, you might not need something as robust as the Hopper M20. If you want the best of the best, get the YETI backpack cooler. But if your budget is tight, look at Icemule.
Pros
  • The best insulating power of any backpack cooler I’ve tested
  • Very comfortable design that’s able to carry a lot of weight without discomfort
  • The MagShield Access opening is fantastic—easy to open and close and it’s perfectly air-tight
Cons
  • The inside has an extremely strong chemical smell that lasts for several weeks
Value (10%)
6
Capacity (10%)
9
Insulation (30%)
9
Durability (20%)
10
Ease Of Use (15%)
10
Portability (10%)
10
Features (5%)
9
Get It Check Price
Specs YETI Hopper M20
ConstructionDryHide high density knit fabric
Does it Fit a Wine or 2L Bottle Standing Upright?Yes
Exterior Dimensions9”x18”x18”
Frosty Brew Rating33 hours
Safe Meat Rating28 hours
True Liquid Capacity20
Weight5.6 lbs empty
Show All Specifications
Compare All
Best on a Budget Badge CoolerSpy
Igloo MaxCold Voyager Backpack Igloo MaxCold Voyager
Overall Score
73
Bottom Line This ugly little beast is the best budget backpack cooler I tested. It held more cans and was better at insulating compared to the Tourit. The Igloo MaxCold Voyager has a great price, though I’d bet you’ll be looking for a new backpack cooler in three or four years, as it’s not the most durable.
Pros
  • Best space efficiency
  • Under $100
  • Lots of pockets make it great for a picnic, where you’re bringing food and drinks
Cons
  • Quite ugly
  • More of an insulated backpack than a true cooler
Value (10%)
9
Capacity (10%)
9
Insulation (30%)
6
Durability (20%)
7
Ease Of Use (15%)
8
Portability (10%)
8
Features (5%)
7
Get It Check Price
Specs Igloo MaxCold Voyager
ConstructionNylon
Does it Fit a Wine or 2L Bottle Standing Upright?Yes
Exterior Dimensions2”x10.7”x17”
Frosty Brew Rating25 hours
Safe Meat Rating19 hours
True Liquid Capacity2
Weight3lbs empty
Show All Specifications

If you’ve ever picked up a hard-sided cooler, you’ve probably thought: why is this so insanely heavy?

The kind of hard coolers YETI made popular are basically indestructible. But they’re also terrible if you want to bring some frosty beverages on the trail with you. 

That’s where backpack coolers enter the equation. 

While I love my hard coolers, I still want to crack a frosty brew when I reach the top of the mountain. But when I started searching for the best backpack cooler, I was overloaded with options. 

To save you the trouble, I bought a bunch. And I tested them all against each other to find out which backpack cooler has the most storage, keeps ice the longest, and is the most comfortable when traveling. 

How Did I Test These Coolers? Why You Should Trust Me

Yeti Hopper M20 compared to rtic backpack and Icemule pro

I’ve got a scientific mind, so I love to dive into all the details and really review these coolers. 

I tested the YETI Hopper M20, the RTIC 20-can Backpack, the Igloo MaxCold Voyager, the Icemule Pro XL 33L, and the Tourit Cockatoo. From what I can see, these are the most popular backpack coolers on the market right now. 

I tested each cooler by placing 3.5lbs of ice and measuring the internal temperature over the course of 40 hours. 

Each test was done in a temperature controlled room in the dark to try and minimize any outside temperature inconsistencies. 

I bought each of these coolers myself—none of them were provided by the brands.

I’ve also taken each of these backpack coolers on a trip and worn them around to get an idea of how they feel and what they’re actually like to use regularly. 

demonstrating yeti air tight seal

And as you can see in the video above, I’ve also done a few “out of the box” experiments with these coolers, too. Leave no stone unturned, as they say. 

I’ve put all my tests and results down below my recommendations if you’re interested in diving into why I ranked certain coolers over the others. 

5 Best Cooler Backpacks in 2023


Our Top Pick Badge CoolerSpy
83
Value for Money Icon
VALUE
10
score
Capacity Icon
CAPACITY
8
score
Insulation Icon
INSULATION
8
score
Durability Icon
DURABILITY
9
score
Ease of Use Icon
EASE OF USE
7
score
Portability Icon
PORTABILITY
9
score
Features Icon
FEATURES
7
score
Measured Capacity Icon True Liquid Capacity:   33
Hours Below Icon Hours Below 40º F:   27 hours
Pros:
  • 100% waterproof if sealed properly
  • 33 liter capacity, which is the most on this list
  • Puncture resistant against fishing hooks and pocket knives
Cons:
  • No separate carrying compartments

The Icemule Pro is a rubberized roll-top backpack and I think it offers the best value for your money. 

While it didn’t outperform the YETI in many aspects like efficiency and ice retention, it’s less than half the cost and it still does a fantastic job on overnight trips. 

model wearin Icemule cooler backpack

Plus, because I do a lot of kayaking and love to be out on a river or lake, I love that I can keep some air in this bag and make it buoyant. 

There are several sizes you can get, but I think the XL 33L is the way to go. 

What I Like

  • The roll top closure is easy to open and close and it keeps water out.
  • It packs really well into a kayak, whether you stuff it in a storage compartment or want to bungee it on to the top. Plus it’ll float if it goes overboard.
  • The ice retention and insulation is excellent—it was the second-best performer in my tests.
  • The inside is quite puncture resistant, even against fish hooks.

What I Don’t Like

  • The rubberized exterior is more prone to being damaged from abrasion, though I think the only situation extreme enough for that to make a difference is if you were doing some intense boulder scrambling and really banging up your backpack.

What Other Reviewers Say

The Icemule Pro L 23L is the most popular backpack cooler in the Icemule Pro line, but I think the extra space in the XL 33L is the way to go (especially because it’s only about $10 more).

With over 200 reviews, the Icemule Pro XL 33L has a 4.9-star rating on the Icemule site.

In the reviews there are a lot of tubers, kayakers, and lake-goers, many of which are trying the Pro as their second or third Icemule product.

I’ve read great things about Icemule’s customer service, too. I didn’t have any issues, so I didn’t need to get in contact with them myself.

The Verdict

The Icemule Pro XL 33L surprised me.

It’s my go-to backpack cooler for when I go kayaking and fishing now. I love the roll top design: it’s easy to get the beers and snacks inside and then to seal it up securely again so that no water can get in.

It fits perfectly onto the front of a kayak, and even if it fell off for some reason, it would just keep on floating.

The insulation was nearly as powerful as the YETI Hopper, which I didn’t expect. And the ergonomic design and loads of padding on the back and shoulders makes this an easy cooler to travel with all day.

Our Top Pick
Icemule Pro XL 33L

The Icemule Pro XL is my top pick for backpack coolers. I love the way it looks, the insulation is fantastic, and the price is right. It can hold its own against YETI despite being less than half the price.

Check Price Buy Now at Icemule
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Upgrade Pick Badge CoolerSpy 1
90
Value for Money Icon
VALUE
6
score
Capacity Icon
CAPACITY
7
score
Insulation Icon
INSULATION
9
score
Durability Icon
DURABILITY
10
score
Ease of Use Icon
EASE OF USE
10
score
Portability Icon
PORTABILITY
10
score
Features Icon
FEATURES
9
score
Measured Capacity Icon True Liquid Capacity:   20
Hours Below Icon Hours Below 40º F:   28 hours
Pros:
  • The best insulating power of any backpack cooler I’ve tested
  • Very comfortable design that’s able to carry a lot of weight without discomfort
  • The MagShield Access opening is fantastic—easy to open and close and it’s perfectly air-tight
Cons:
  • The inside has an extremely strong chemical smell that lasts for several weeks

The YETI Hopper M20 is the best backpack cooler all around. It’s also the most expensive. 

To be honest, I mostly use the YETI Hopper M20 (unless I’m going kayaking, where I use the Icemule). It’s the most durable of the backpack coolers I tested, and the magnetic opening strip on top is borderline magical. 

Yeti Hopper M20 front view white background

If your main concern is quality and money is lower on the priority list, then the YETI Hopper M20 is the best way to go. 

What I Like

  • The YETI Hopper M20 has the best insulating power of all the backpack coolers I tested.
  • It has a comfortable and secure design that makes it easy to carry a lot of weight, even when on uneven terrain.
  • The MagShield Access opening is awesome—I love that it’s airtight so I don’t have to worry about water seeping in.

What I Don’t Like

  • The inside of the cooler had a really strong chemical smell for several weeks (even when I aired it out).

What Other Reviewers Say

The reviews for the YETI Hopper M20 are mixed on the YETI site. Some love theirs, and others really don’t.

I’ve found with coolers it’s difficult for a single person to judge the effectiveness of one cooler against another, which is why I buy several and test them against one another.

Only one other reviewer mentioned the smell, so I’m thinking my crazy smelling cooler may have been an outlier.

The Verdict

If you put a lot of demand on your gear, then the YETI Hopper M20 is worth the money. It’s the most durable of the backpack coolers I tested, and it also holds ice the longest.

The YETI Hopper is the better choice for more land-based adventures like hikes and rock climbing.

While the YETI Hopper M20 is far more expensive than the competition, I think the high density fabric shell is absolutely worth it from a longevity perspective.

That said, if you’ll only ever just take your cooler to the pool, then durability isn’t so important, and any of the other coolers will do fine and hold your drinks cold for the day.

But if you want a backpack cooler that can keep up with the most rigorous demands, then the YETI Hopper M20 is the clear winner.

Upgrade Pick
YETI Hopper M20 Backpack Cooler

The Hopper M20 Backpack Soft Cooler allows you to put the day on your back — literally. This hands-free soft cooler keeps you mobile, while an ultra-strong magnet strip keeps the cold locked in and the hot air out.

Buy Now at YETI Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Best on a Budget Badge CoolerSpy
73
Value for Money Icon
VALUE
9
score
Capacity Icon
CAPACITY
8
score
Insulation Icon
INSULATION
6
score
Durability Icon
DURABILITY
7
score
Ease of Use Icon
EASE OF USE
8
score
Portability Icon
PORTABILITY
8
score
Features Icon
FEATURES
7
score
Pros:
  • Best space efficiency
  • Under $100
  • Lots of pockets make it great for a picnic, where you’re bringing food and drinks
Cons:
  • Quite ugly
  • More of an insulated backpack than a true cooler

I appreciate Igloo. They always make these ugly little coolers that perform really well in all my cooler tests. They know what they do best. 

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager is a fantastic backpack cooler under $100. Sure, it doesn’t keep ice as long as the YETI or RTIC, but in a lot of ways, it’s also more practical. 

Igloo backpack cooler on kayak in lake

Because the Igloo MaxCold Voyager has three major compartments, you can carry a wide variety of items and keep them separated. I think this is an ideal setup for parents, when you need to have snackies at the ready. 

Sure, the bulbous pastel design might not make you look like a wandering ranger, but I’d bet you can access your chilled orange slices in three seconds, flat. 

What I Like

  • I like the three separate compartments—it acts more like an insulated backpack than a cooler you can carry on your back.
  • Of the sub-$100 coolers I tested, Igloo had the best insulation.
  • Igloo put a lot of thought into their features: elastic mesh sides, metal bottle opener, t-handles on the zippers, elastic bungee on the front, and nylon webbing on the left strap.

What I Don’t Like

  • Because the Igloo is built like an insulated backpack rather than a cooler, there are some gaps in the insulation that cause it to underperform compared to other brands (though it still was the best sub-$100 backpack cooler for insulation in my tests).
  • Compared to the other backpack coolers I got, I think it’s the worst looking.

What Other Reviewers Say

Some reviewers were dismayed that this backpack doesn’t carry a full 30 cans with ice—just 30 cans without ice. Who wants that?

I think a better expectation is 20 cans with ice, plus places to store your phone, keys, and wallet. In that regard, the Igloo has the most pockets of any cooler I tested, so it has the most versatile storage space. The higher end coolers usually just have one main compartment—the Igloo is much more of an insulated backpack, rather than a cooler you can put on your back.

The Verdict

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager is my top budget-friendly backpack cooler.

It outperformed the Tourit Cockatoo in just about every way (except I think the Tourit looks cooler, but that’s really not that big of a deal).

The waterproof lining in the Igloo is pretty thin, and I can see something catching it and tearing it fairly easily—then it’s game over for the cooler.

If you get the Igloo MaxCold Voyager, I think you’ll be happy with your purchase. And I also think you’ll be buying another backpack cooler within the next five years. The Icemule might sting a bit more on the upfront costs, but I bet it would be the last backpack cooler you’ll need.

Best Budget
Igloo MaxCold Voyager Backpack

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager offers solid value for money, and if you need a cooler backpack for an upcoming trip, it's not a bad choice. I don't see this lasting more than 5 years though, and I personally would rather get something that I know will last a decade or longer.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
Best for Beach
70
Value for Money Icon
VALUE
7
score
Capacity Icon
CAPACITY
6
score
Insulation Icon
INSULATION
7
score
Durability Icon
DURABILITY
8
score
Ease of Use Icon
EASE OF USE
6
score
Portability Icon
PORTABILITY
7
score
Features Icon
FEATURES
7
score
Pros:
  • The top is very secure, so once your backpack is closed, nothing is going to come out
  • The shape is easy to store and pack in the back of a car
  • It can keep food-safe temperatures for 24 hours (with 3.5lbs of ice)
Cons:
  • It’s not as comfortable to wear on hikes as some competitors
  • The zipper is difficult to open and close
  • Its capacity and insulation lags behind at least one other similarly priced competitor
model grabbing beverage from RTIC backpack cooler

The biggest win for the RTIC backpack cooler is when I put two expensive bottles of wine in it and charged a huge hill on a golf-cart—the cooler flew off the back of the cart. And both bottles of wine were spared. 

So that made me love this cooler no matter what. 

RTIC backpack cooler 11

But it’s not the most comfortable to wear, and I don’t recommend it for hikes or anything that requires you to focus on your balance. The rectangular shape doesn’t sit well on your back when fully loaded, so it can shift and cause you to slip if you’re trying to scramble over a boulder. 

But if you’re having a chill day at the beach and it’s your job to bring the cold cervezas to the party, the RTIC 20-can Backpack Cooler is the best option. It holds 20 cans, with ice, and has no problem keeping things under 40 degrees for 24 hours. 

What I Like

  • With the stiff zipper, the top is very secure (and watertight), so once your backpack is closed, nothing is coming out.
  • The shape makes it easy to store in the back of the car and the handles make it easy to shift around.
  • With 3.5lbs of ice, the RTIC maintains food-safe temperatures for 24 hours.

What I Don’t Like

  • It’s the least comfortable backpack design of the five I tried.
  • The zipper can be extremely difficult to open and close.

What Other Reviewers Say

Over 200 reviews on the RTIC website give the Backpack Cooler a 4.6-star rating. The 30-Can definitely seems to be the most popular of the two (I got the 20-Can to more accurately compare against the competition in terms of liter capacity).

The zipper is one consistent negative where there are complaints, and a few guys mentioned the straps being a bit small.

But the vast majority of reviews are five-star for the RTIC Backpack Cooler.

The Verdict

I like the RTIC Backpack Cooler, but when I compare it to the YETI Hopper M20 and the Icemule Pro, it falls a little flat for me.

But there’s a specific reason.

Whenever I go anywhere that I would usually bring a cooler along, it’s usually some intense hike with boulder scrambling, kayaking, or some other high-impact activity.

When I bring my RTIC Backpack Cooler along, it’s because I’m hanging out with my friends and their kids at the pool. It’s a great cooler, but maybe because I like the other activities better, I have an affinity for the YETI and the Icemule.

Still, if it was my job to bring the chilled drinks to the beach and I didn’t have to carry the cooler far, I’d pick the RTIC Backpack Cooler all day.

Best for Beach
RTIC 20-can Backpack Cooler

This insulated cooler backpack is perfect for a day hiking, camping, picnic, fishing, a day on the beach, or at the pool. A hands-free carry cooler bag that straps comfortably to your back, leaving both arms free for what your adventure calls for. It will keep your food and drinks cool wherever needed.

Check Price Buy Now at RTIC
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Best Under $50: Tourit Cockatoo Backpack Cooler

5.
Tourit Cockatoo Cooler Backpack

The Tourit Cockatoo isn't great with insulation. It's better to think of it as a backpack with insulation rather than a cooler. If you need a lot of compartments and only need to keep a chill for six hours or so, the Tourit Cockatoo is great. But for all-day frostiness, you'll want something more robust.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

You might notice in my test results and analysis section below that the Tourit Cockatoo got beat up on every test. It was pretty much last place for everything I closely looked at. 

But it’s important to note that it’s still a solid cooler backpack. For one thing, it’s the only backpack cooler I tested that was under $50. 

The Tourit Cockatoo is more like an insulated backpack than a true cooler, so I wouldn’t store perishables overnight in it. But if you’re just packing some snacks and drinks for the afternoon, then the Cockatoo is a fantastic, inexpensive choice. 

What I Like

  • The Tourit Cockatoo has a lot of handy pockets, so it’s great for stashing your keys, wallet, and picnic items.
  • It’s the least expensive option on this list.

What I Don’t Like

  • Shipping took several weeks.
  • It performed the worst on my ice retention tests.

What Other Reviewers Say

Reviewers had a wide-range of use cases, from day hikes to long bus rides, to packing away bodybuilding supplements—most reviewers used it like a backpack and not like a cooler (big difference there).

When I ordered from Tourit, I did get my shipping information in Chinese, and it’s shipped directly from China. So you can imagine that it takes quite a while to actually arrive, and when it does, it’s basically crammed into a small plastic bag.

So myself and some other reviewers were a bit dismayed at that fact, but at the end of the day, a cooler is a cooler.

The Verdict

While the Tourit Cockatoo didn’t win any blue ribbons at the fair, it’s the best backpack cooler you can get under $50.

Don’t expect anything fancy (in fact, expect it to arrive three weeks after you buy it crammed into a plastic bag).

But if you need a cheap bag that’ll keep your food and drinks chilled for an afternoon, then the Tourit Cockatoo will get the job done.

Best Under $50
Tourit Cockatoo Cooler Backpack

The Tourit Cockatoo isn't great with insulation. It's better to think of it as a backpack with insulation rather than a cooler. If you need a lot of compartments and only need to keep a chill for six hours or so, the Tourit Cockatoo is great. But for all-day frostiness, you'll want something more robust.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Best Backpack Coolers: Test Results and Analysis

To come up with the list above, I did a series of tests to get some hard data. I also just tested the coolers on trips like a normal person. 

My tests for the backpack coolers were:

  • Measuring the internal temperature for 40 hours with 3.5 lbs of ice
  • Measuring how many cans each could hold
  • Dividing the number of cans a cooler could hold by its total liter capacity (efficiency)
  • Real life tests, like how it felt and how easy it was to carry

Let’s dive into each. 

Value

RTIC backpack cooler at winery

Value for money is subjective, because sometimes a certain feature makes a cooler worth any amount of money (ok, maybe not that extreme, but you get what I’m saying). 

But for me, the Icemule Pro XL 33L is the best value-for-money adventure-ready cooler on the market. 

The Icemule successfully keeps food-safe temperatures for over 24 hours and it’s easy to throw on your back, even when it’s full of ice and drinks. So it checks the main boxes for me. 

size of Icemule relative to person

If I had to pick a favorite backpack cooler, costs aside, I’d pick the YETI Hopper M20 because it’s the most snug and secure on my back and the high density fabric is a bit stiffer and more durable. 

I still choose the Icemule as my top pick overall because it costs less than half of what the YETI does. 

The RTIC is roughly the same cost as the Icemule, but it’s not as easy to take on adventures and walk any distances with. It also doesn’t match the Icemule’s insulation power. 

The Igloo and Tourit are the least expensive, but I almost see them as a different category—both are more like insulated backpacks, rather than coolers that can be worn on your back. 

Capacity

adding cans into RTIC backpack cooler

You can’t go off of liquid quart capacity alone. How much a cooler carries really depends on the internal dimensions of the cooler. So two coolers could have the same liquid capacity but have totally different practical capacities. 

So I created a measurement called the “space efficiency ratio.” It’s the liter volume divided by number of cans the cooler can hold with ice included. Here’s how all the backpack coolers compared against one another:

backpack cooler space efficiency compared

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager was the big winner in this category because it has two pockets. It can technically hold more cans, though I have to note that the insulation on the outer pocket is probably not nearly as good as its main compartment—and even that wasn’t great comparatively. 

Igloo MaxCold Voyager Backpack

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager offers solid value for money, and if you need a cooler backpack for an upcoming trip, it's not a bad choice. I don't see this lasting more than 5 years though, and I personally would rather get something that I know will last a decade or longer.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Still, the Igloo’s ugly design is great for holding a lot of cans.  

With both the Icemule and the YETI Hopper M20, you could pack a picnic for 6, including 12 cans, sandwiches, and some fruit to go along with as well as a few pounds of ice.

counting how many cans fit into yeti backpack cooler

I prefer the size of the YETI and the Icemule over the other packs—even if they’re less efficient, they still have more room overall. 

Here are the actual capacities for all the coolers tested:

Backpack cooler actual capacity in liters

The Icemule has the most liquid capacity, but it’s not as efficient with the space as the YETI, RTIC, or Igloo. The Icemule is large enough that you should also take into consideration the weight—these things can get over 50 lbs when fully loaded with ice and drinks. 

model wearing Icemule pro on back

I think 50 lbs is fine for a healthy man to hike with all day, but that weight might be a bit too much for other folks. 

Icemule Pro XL 33L

The Icemule Pro XL is my top pick for backpack coolers. I love the way it looks, the insulation is fantastic, and the price is right. It can hold its own against YETI despite being less than half the price.

Check Price Buy Now at Icemule
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Insulation

YETI had the best insulation performance and held ice the longest

Backpack Cooler Ice Retention and Insulating Ability Graph 1

I ran my test for 40 hours, at which point all the other coolers had been sitting at room temperature. Only the YETI was still below room temperature at 40 hours, but not by enough that it was worth continuing the test.

Yeti Hopper M20 backpack cooler on fishing trip

The Icemule came in second and held its contents below 40 degrees (the food-safe temperature limit) for 27 hours. The RTIC held that temperature for 24 hours, and the YETI held that temp for 28 hours.

How long can a backpack cooler hold ice for?

The best insulating cooler backpack, the YETI Hopper M20, held ice for 25 hours. The average length of ice-retention for a backpack cooler is 19 hours.

question icon

The Igloo and Tourit held at or below 40 degrees for 19 hours. 

Igloo voyager backpack cooler on a kayak in lake

And if it’s frosty beers you’re after, the Icemule kept cans at or below 50 degrees for 32 hours, compared to the YETI’s 33-hour performance. 

So while the YETI Hopper M20 was the king of insulation in my tests, you can see that the Icemule wasn’t far behind at all, which really surprised me.

YETI Hopper M20 Backpack Cooler

The Hopper M20 Backpack Soft Cooler allows you to put the day on your back — literally. This hands-free soft cooler keeps you mobile, while an ultra-strong magnet strip keeps the cold locked in and the hot air out.

Buy Now at YETI Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Durability

Yeti Hopper M20

Durability is harder to test, but I actually got a good chance to put several of these coolers through rigorous real-world conditions. 

Like I said, I did a lot of river scrambling with the YETI Hopper M20 and it performed really well. With the RTIC 20-can, it flew off the back of an off-road golf cart while jamming up a hill—it had two bottles of super nice wine in it and kept them both safe. And the Icemule went on a fishing trip with me and had a bunch of hooks and lures bouncing around inside it.

nOpB1HqxPJ40TPZRTLXzplK 35 kWCFjWMAV9TevpFf4U AhAyM LITZjcXAeUhCD7sDfs90gua P00gM94MRjVZ5Mdco1YGxTGDoAcp o12GzsXO0WgRHkIBhVv7 CtvnzNUa8 n nvtaXyER66xIsl7Q2go4WJxH8zX9PZE njasAZ d9gP6ofCBW A

While they all held up just fine, my feeling is that the YETI Hopper is the most durable. The shell is a high density fabric that feels much more stiff than any of the competitors. 

I’d say the YETI is the best suited for rugged travel. 

I’m a little less confident in the RTIC and Icemule because their shells are a sort of rubberized fabric that seems like it could tear if really stressed. 

RTIC backpack cooler

That said, it wouldn’t be fair to say that either aren’t durable—they are, and probably plenty durable for whatever you’re planning. But the YETI’s harder shell seems more sturdy. 

Portability

Icemule pro close up image

The biggest draw of a backpack cooler is its portability, especially when you compare it to a hard cooler. 

The YETI Hopper M20 is my favorite cooler backpack in terms of comfort. 

The Icemule is right behind it, but the YETI felt much more balanced on my back, which also makes it safer. 

Yeti Hopper M20 backpack on shoreline

And that’s one of the reasons I actually don’t think the extraordinary price difference between YETI and the other brands is too extreme. 

If you’re doing something that’s a little dangerous like scrambling over boulders, having something that sits secure and comfortably on your back is important. The YETI does this the best, which is why I recommend stumping up the extra cash if your hikes tend to get more wild than the average. 

Like for me, I rarely turn down the chance to hop over a few rocks to get to the best view. So over time, the slimmer design and more secure fit makes the higher cost more and more reasonable.

The Icemule is also very comfortable and easy to use, and I actually prefer it for kayaking because it holds more air and doubles as a dry bag. But the extra size and softer rubber shell can be a liability if I’m around sharp or abrasive rocks. 

RTIC Backpack White background 3

The RTIC backpack cooler is just a big square you put on your back. It’s not uncomfortable, but it’s a big square. 

DafhaxP3kCQeYm0GBrQLQGmMA 5zRso24WbFLWMKb6vPudNxwb95HOAP d1hXOQ4fuF0zzpvnmVaDFINAGEvN2eI15w UXa0ecCpQ4KERTbeLrCf1yvjAPTcZO97VThq4DHeZTCct6tkZw9jwaeHOIwTLGUyUcQxHoXMicKVEoP CM08rbVlxi0jrJHR Q

Both the Tourit and Igloo were decent in terms of portability. They’re like any regular backpack, and carrying them felt like the first day of school when you’d get all your textbooks at once and have to lean forward to lug them from class to class.

Which Cooler is Right For You?

If I were only getting one backpack cooler and wanted the best value for my money, I’d pick the Icemule Pro XL 33L

Our Top Pick
Icemule Pro XL 33L

The Icemule Pro XL is my top pick for backpack coolers. I love the way it looks, the insulation is fantastic, and the price is right. It can hold its own against YETI despite being less than half the price.

Check Price Buy Now at Icemule
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

It’s puncture proof, floats in water, keeps food and drinks under 40 degrees for over 24 hours, and is really comfortable to hike with. And the price is very reasonable. 

If you’re ready to spend and want the absolute best quality, then get the YETI Hopper M20. The YETI performed the best all-around in my tests and it’s built like a tank. 

Upgrade Pick
YETI Hopper M20 Backpack Cooler

The Hopper M20 Backpack Soft Cooler allows you to put the day on your back — literally. This hands-free soft cooler keeps you mobile, while an ultra-strong magnet strip keeps the cold locked in and the hot air out.

Buy Now at YETI Read Our Review
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

And if you’re on a strict budget, check out the Igloo CoolMax Voyager. It’s not the best looking cooler backpack, but it gets the job done and carries a lot. 

Best on a Budget
Igloo MaxCold Voyager Backpack

The Igloo MaxCold Voyager offers solid value for money, and if you need a cooler backpack for an upcoming trip, it's not a bad choice. I don't see this lasting more than 5 years though, and I personally would rather get something that I know will last a decade or longer.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Now let’s get to the fun part: where are you going to take your new cooler?

FAQs

What is comparable to a YETI backpack cooler?

In all my tests, the Icemule Pro XL 33L came the closest to YETI and costs less than half the price of the YETI Hopper M20 backpack cooler.

How do I choose a backpack cooler?

The most important considerations in choosing a backpack cooler break down like this:
1. It’s comfortable to wear when walking and doesn’t throw off your balance
2. It’s air-tight, so if it falls into the water, it floats
3. It’s durable and puncture resistant, so if it gets snagged, it won’t tear and get ruined
4. It keeps food colder than 40 degrees for at least 12 hours—preferably 24 or more

Is an Igloo cooler as good as a YETI?

In terms of insulation and durability, Igloo coolers are generally worse than YETI coolers. But they’re also much less expensive and can give you many of the same practical benefits. A YETI cooler might be able to keep food under 40 degrees for six days, but if you only need to keep food cool for 56 hours, then many Igloo’s can do that, too.